Codes

Vitamins, protein and supplements

A £2 billion UK market where the evidence runs from solid (vitamin D in winter, creatine for training) to thin (most of the rest). This section says which is which, how to read a label, and where to compare prices.

Vitamins and supplement capsules on a green surface
Photo: Jonathan Borba on Pexels

Vitamin D

The one supplement with official backing for the whole population. From October to March the UK sun is too weak to make any, and a 10 microgram tablet costs about 3p.

Omega-3 fish oil

Two portions of fish a week, one of them oily, is the NHS advice. If you do not eat fish, a capsule fills the gap. If you do, it adds little.

Magnesium

The supplement of the moment, sold for sleep, stress and cramps. The evidence for most of that is thin, but a deficiency is common enough that a cheap tablet is a fair bet for some people.

Multivitamins

Insurance for a patchy diet, not a health upgrade. The large trials show no effect on heart disease or cancer in well-fed adults. For some groups, a cheap one still earns its place.

Protein powder

Food first, powder when food falls short. Most adults need 0.75g of protein per kilo a day; people training hard or losing weight on a GLP-1 medicine need up to twice that, and a shake is the cheapest way to close the gap.

Creatine

Hundreds of trials, one cheap white powder. Creatine adds strength and lean mass to resistance training, and the evidence for older adults and brain function is growing.

Collagen

A protein you digest into pieces, sold on the promise that the pieces tell your skin to make more. The trials are small and mostly funded by makers, but they do point in one direction.

Probiotics

Live bacteria sold as food, with evidence for a few specific uses and a lot of hope for the rest. The NHS view is that they are probably safe and probably do little for most people.

What the evidence supports

Vitamin D for everyone in autumn and winter, which is NHS advice. Folic acid before and in early pregnancy. B12 for vegans and most people over 65. Iron for people who test low. Creatine monohydrate for anyone doing resistance training. Protein powder as a convenient way to hit a daily target you cannot reach with food. Omega-3 for people who eat no oily fish. Beyond that list, the returns drop sharply: a multivitamin is insurance for a poor diet, collagen has early evidence for skin and joints, and most herbal products have none.

How to compare prices

Work out the price per dose, not per pack. A 240-tablet vitamin D bottle at £8 is 3p a day; a 30-capsule designer version at £15 is 50p for the same 1,000 IU. For protein, divide the price by grams of protein in the tub: a 1kg whey at £32 with 23g protein per 30g serving holds about 770g of protein, so 4.2p a gram. For creatine, 3g to 5g a day from a 500g tub at £10 is 6p to 10p a day. Own brands from Myprotein, Bulk, Boots and Holland & Barrett undercut the branded names by half or more and the active ingredient is the same.

Promotions move daily

Sports nutrition retailers run permanent sales, with a crossed-out price and a code on top. The real price is what you pay at checkout, and it changes week to week. This site does not yet track supplement prices live, so the retailer lists below link to the product category and the guides show example prices with the date they were read. Treat them as a yardstick, not a quote.

Reading the label

Look for the amount per dose in micrograms, milligrams or IU and compare it with the NHS reference intake. Check the form: vitamin D3 over D2, magnesium glycinate or citrate over oxide if you want absorption, methylcobalamin or cyanocobalamin for B12 both work. For protein, check protein per serving and the ingredients list for fillers. Supplements in the UK are regulated as foods, so claims on the label are limited by law; a product promising to cure anything is breaking it.

Questions people ask

Which supplements are worth taking?

Vitamin D in autumn and winter, creatine if you lift, protein powder if you cannot reach your protein target with food, B12 if you are vegan or over 65, iron if a test shows you are low, and folic acid if you could become pregnant. The rest depends on your diet and a blood test.

Are own-brand supplements as good as branded?

Yes, for the active ingredient. UK food supplement law applies to all of them. The difference is the form, the dose and the price.

Can I take too much?

Yes. Vitamin D above 100 micrograms (4,000 IU) a day can cause harm over time, iron without a deficiency causes stomach problems and can be dangerous, and vitamin A in pregnancy is a risk. Stay within the NHS upper limits.

Does this site compare supplement prices live?

Not yet. It links to the retailer categories and shows example prices with the date they were read. Live supplement prices need a retailer feed and are on the plan.

Sources